Many leadership teams mistake an AI plan for a strategy—don’t be that team!

Are misconceptions tripping you up?

For many years, I coached business leaders in soft skills, including strategy formulation. During coaching sessions, I’d ask them to raise their hands if they thought they were good at business strategy. Most, if not all, would raise a hand. Then I’d ask for volunteers to explain what a strategy is. Far fewer hands went up. When I selected someone to explain, the answer usually sounded like a weak execution plan.

The explanation usually went something like this: brainstorm ideas, discuss the ideas, vote on the ideas, select the most popular idea or the one promoted by the leader, and then spend the rest of the time discussing how to implement it. When I asked the other attendees how they felt about that explanation, most were good with it.

These senior leaders, the people responsible for running their businesses, didn’t know the difference between a strategy and a plan.

The situation is even worse when it comes to AI strategy. What often passes for an AI strategy is for top management to declare that AI adoption is a high priority, give people access to tools such as ChatGPT, and expect everyone to experiment and run pilots to improve their work somehow. What they learn and their successes are to be shared with the rest of the organization.

Management then receives a quarterly progress report boasting about tool usage and the number of pilots rather than showing whether any of it is improving business results.

This isn’t even a good AI plan, let alone an AI strategy.

With that approach, it’s hardly surprising when meaningful business benefits fail to materialize.

I think there are two misconceptions behind this sad state of affairs.

The first is that AI is like some kind of magic high-tech grease: just apply it where there’s friction, and everything will move faster and more smoothly.

The second is that people mistake planning how to implement an idea for deciding whether it is the right idea to pursue—and what they should choose not to pursue.

What should you do with AI?

Simple question—hard answer.

When I ask leaders this question, there is an initial deer-in-the-headlights expression. But leaders are smart, so they quickly recover with an answer, something like, “Lower costs, reduce headcount, or improve customer service.”

“Can you be more specific?” I’ll ask.

The deer-in-the-headlights look returns.

I’m not trying to be unkind to smart people. But I want to demonstrate how those two misconceptions are really messing them up.

To properly answer the question “What should we do with AI?” we first need to break it into smaller questions. The sequence of those questions is very important.

  • What are our priority business problems?

  • Where could AI help resolve those problems?

  • Which of those opportunities should we pursue—and which should we not pursue?

AI may not be the best answer to every priority problem. That, too, is a strategic decision.

Notice that we haven’t started discussing implementation details yet. Those belong in plans. First, we’re deciding which problems deserve our attention and which uses of AI are worth pursuing.

Another important aspect of deciding what you will do is deciding what you will not do—and sticking to those choices. Being clear about both is critical for keeping decisions throughout the organization aligned with the direction and priorities you have set.

Reflective Question No. 1

During meetings, discussions, or brainstorming, do people routinely use your strategy to explain why an idea should—or should not—be pursued?

You might hear something like, “That’s a great idea, but it doesn’t align with our strategy.”

If not, your strategy may not be pulling its weight throughout the organization.

You can’t do everything at once

I’m stating the obvious because I have to. People will agree with this and then turn around and make decisions and take actions as though they are trying to do everything at once.

Since time, money, and people’s attention are limited, we want to get the greatest benefit from the resources and effort we invest. Part of strategy formulation is considering the trade-offs when setting the direction.

Choosing one opportunity may mean delaying or declining another—even when both have potential. That’s part of making a strategic choice.

Strategy requires self-discipline

A good strategy makes the priorities, boundaries, and reasons behind them clear. It also establishes how decisions that fall outside those boundaries will be reviewed.

But those choices have to influence what actually gets approved, funded, and done. Otherwise, they’re just words.

This does not mean the strategy should never be challenged or reviewed. But if a strategic choice no longer makes sense, challenge it openly and get it changed. Don’t quietly ignore it.

A strategy is a guideline, not a comprehensive list of do’s and don’ts

Leaders can’t foresee every issue their employees will face. A clear strategy gives people a basis for making decisions without requiring leaders to prescribe every response.

When an issue arises, the person dealing with it can ask, “Does the response we are considering align with our strategy—in other words, with the direction and priorities that have been set?”

If the answer is no, they don’t proceed with that response. If they are unsure, they can ask higher-ups a specific question about where it fits and seek a decision.

Reflective Question No. 2

If an employee has an AI budget and several options for spending it, are your strategic priorities clear enough to help her rule out options that don’t fit?

Would another person in the same role, with the same information, rule out broadly the same options?

If not, your AI strategy may not be clear enough to guide decisions.

Strategy formulation is an iterative exercise

When formulating a strategy, it’s perfectly fine to adjust as you go. In fact, it’s required.

As new information comes in, you will want to cycle through the same three questions:

  • What are our priority business problems?

  • Where could AI help resolve those problems?

  • Which of those opportunities should we pursue—and which should we not pursue?

Then adjust your answers as required.

Some people get trapped in linear thinking. They feel like going back and adjusting something that has already been covered is going backward.

Don’t be one of those people. This is a refining process. A stronger rationale gives you a better basis for making decisions.

Strategy formulation is both easy and hard work

Following a framework to avoid the pitfalls we’ve been discussing is the easy part. Doing the rigorous work to develop the rationale behind your final decisions takes more effort.

You need to be able to explain why these problems deserve priority, why the selected opportunities are worth pursuing, and why other opportunities will have to wait.

That is a very different exercise from brainstorming ideas and choosing a popular one.

Once the strategic choices are clear, the next step is to turn them into specific goals: what results you want, how you will measure them, how much improvement you expect, by when, and within what constraints. Those goals then give your implementation plans something concrete to deliver.

But that’s the subject of a subsequent post.

Until next time,
Jerry

Next
Next

Why You Can’t Delegate AI Transformation